Skip to content

Hayway

News

Abuse of Power: Causes, Consequences and Possible Remedies

The term “abuse of power” covers distinct legal concepts depending on whether it concerns a public official, a company director or a relationship of…

Cadre supérieur en position dominante face à une employée intimidée dans un bureau d'entreprise, illustrant l'abus de pouvoir en milieu professionnel

The term “abuse of power” covers distinct legal situations depending on whether it involves a public official, a company director or a workplace relationship between colleagues. Under French law, there is no general offence by that name: the Criminal Code punishes abuse of authority by a person vested with public authority (Articles 432-1 et seq.), while the Commercial Code penalises abuse of a director’s powers.

In the workplace, the employer’s duties to prevent and respond to misconduct also apply when the alleged perpetrator is a colleague or a client—not just a line manager.

Abuse of power at work: when the perpetrator is not a line manager

Most articles on the subject limit abuse of authority to the traditional relationship of subordination between a manager and their subordinate. This view is incomplete. A report of harassment or undue pressure can engage the employer’s liability even if the alleged perpetrator is a colleague or a client. The employer remains responsible for protecting employees’ physical and mental health, regardless of the status of the person accused.

In practice, there are two challenges. First, employees who are victims often hesitate to report incidents when the perpetrator is at the same level in the hierarchy, because they do not know whom to approach. Second, the employer may be tempted to downplay the situation when there is no formal relationship of authority.

To clarify abuse of power under the Criminal Code, it is important to distinguish the strict criminal-law definition (reserved for public officials or company directors) from the broader framework of employment law, which does not require a hierarchical relationship for a company to be held liable.

The Défenseur des droits recommends conducting an internal investigation within no more than two months of a report. This recommendation is a practical benchmark, distinct from a general legal obligation, but an employer that remains passive risks being held liable before the labour court.

Stressed woman reviewing official documents at her kitchen table, symbolising the personal consequences of an abuse of power

Repeated similar conduct and the legal definition of workplace bullying

One point of law that is often misunderstood concerns the nature of the alleged conduct. The behaviours do not have to be different in nature to constitute repetition for the purposes of workplace bullying. Repeated remarks of the same kind, systematic exclusion or repeated removal of responsibilities may be sufficient.

Recent case law requires the facts to be examined as a whole, taking into account any medical evidence submitted by the employee. This holistic approach prevents the employer from challenging each incident in isolation to downplay its significance. It does not mean that bullying is automatically established in every situation, but it requires the judge to consider the body of evidence rather than assess each incident separately.

What this approach means in practice

For employees, this means that a detailed log can be admissible evidence, even if it describes incidents that seem minor and similar. A medical certificate confirming anxiety or depression linked to working conditions strengthens the case.

For employers, inaction in response to repeated reports of the same type of behaviour can no longer be justified by arguing that the conduct is trivial.

Whistleblower protection: the 2022 law and its extensions

Fear of retaliation deters many people from reporting misconduct. The 2022 Waserman Law strengthened whistleblower protections, but one question remained open: does this protection cover reports made before the law came into force?

Protection applies to earlier reports if the retaliatory measure was taken after the 2022 law came into force. This interpretation in case law has practical implications: an employee who reported incidents in 2021 and was dismissed or demoted after 2022 may invoke the current protective regime.

The practical value of this distinction is that the date of the initial report and the date of any subsequent adverse measure should be documented separately. A strong case depends on this timeline.

Common forms of retaliation after a report

  • An unjustified change of assignment, with no objective reason, made in the weeks following the report
  • Exclusion from projects or meetings the employee usually attended, with no written explanation
  • A negative performance review despite meeting targets, with a suspicious timing in relation to the report
  • Non-renewal of a contract or removal of a discretionary bonus in a context where retaliation is documented

Each of these measures, taken in isolation, may appear to fall within the employer’s normal management powers. It is their timing in relation to the report that allows the judge to assess whether they may have been retaliatory.

Determined lawyer reviewing a case file in the corridor of a courthouse, representing legal remedies against abuses of power

Legal remedies and procedures: choosing the right route for the circumstances

The choice of remedy depends on the perpetrator’s status and the nature of the conduct. Three main routes are available:

  • An action to set aside an administrative decision for excess of power before the administrative court challenges decisions by public authorities that exceed their powers or use them for a purpose other than the public interest. This action does not automatically suspend the decision: the contested measure remains in force until the court annuls it
  • Criminal proceedings (Articles 432-1 et seq. of the Criminal Code) concern abuse of authority by people vested with public authority in the performance of their duties. Private-sector employees are not covered, except in very specific cases
  • Applying to the labour court remains the main route for employees who are victims of harassment or undue pressure at work, whether the perpetrator is a manager, a colleague or a third party working with the company

Under administrative law, an application for interim suspension can temporarily halt the enforcement of a measure, provided that urgency and serious doubt as to the decision’s legality are demonstrated. This expedited procedure is often the first useful step when challenging an administrative decision.

Employees unsure which route to take should consult a lawyer before filing a complaint or application. The precise legal classification determines which court has jurisdiction and which deadlines apply. Choosing the wrong route does not permanently forfeit your rights, but it can add several months to the proceedings.

One final point to bear in mind: the burden of proof varies depending on the type of case. In workplace bullying cases before the labour court, the employee must present evidence suggesting that bullying occurred; the employer must then prove that the alleged conduct was justified by objective factors. This adjustment to the burden of proof offers real protection, provided that a factual record has been compiled from the first incidents.

Abuse of Power: Causes, Consequences and Possible Remedies